The Varsity Show has evolved continually over the years, but has always been a full-length musical written, composed, directed, choreographed, designed, produced and performed entirely by undergraduate students. 

The distinguished roster of Columbians who have contributed and participated in The Varsity Show includes a who’s who of show business talent and achievement. Among the more notable alums are Oscar Hammerstein II (CC 1916), Richard Rodgers (CC 1923), Lorenz Hart (CC 1918), I.A.L. Diamond (CC 1941), Herman Wouk (CC 1934), Terrance McNally (CC 1960), and Ed Kelban (CC 1960) who wrote the lyrics for A Chorus Line.

More recent alumni who have added to Varsity Show's rich and vibrant history, include Tom Kitt (CC 1996), Brian Yorkey (CC 1993), Jeanine Tesori (BC 1983), Greta Gerwig (BC 2006), and Kate McKinnon (CC 2006).